Multiple choice

Directions: Read the following information and answer the given question.

Spelunkers International offers exploring tours in eight caves: Abbott, Benny, Caeser, Dangerfield, Ewell, Fields, Guinness and Hope.

(1) Class 1 spelunkers may not explore cave Ewell, Fields or Hope. (2) Class 2 spelunkers may not explore Hope. (3) Class 3 spelunkers may explore any cave. (4) Cave Caesar may be explored only by spelunkers who have previously explored cave Benny. (5) Cave Fields may be explored only by spelunkers who have previously explored cave Ewell. (6) Only two of caves Benny, Caeser, Ewell, Fields and Hope may be explored by any explorer in a single tour.

A class 2 spelunker, who has previously explored cave Ewell, may be restricted in choosing a tour by which of these rules?

I. Rule (4) II. Rule (5) III. Rule (6)

  1. Only I

  2. Only II

  3. Both I and III

  4. Both II and III

  5. I, II and III

Reveal answer Fill a bubble to check yourself
C Correct answer
Explanation

Rule 4 restricts Caesar exploration until Benny is completed - this applies since Caesar is in the selectable pool. Rule 5 restricts Fields until Ewell is completed, but since the spelunker has done Ewell, this doesn't actually constrain. Rule 6 always restricts selection to 2 from {Benny, Caesar, Ewell, Fields, Hope}. Therefore rules 4 and 6 are the active constraints.