Directions: The following question contains some basic principle and fact situation in which these basic principles have to be applied. A list of probable decision and reasons are given. you have to choose a decision with reason.(1) If a person commits an act by which death is caused to another person and the act is done with the intention of causing death, that person is liable for murder (2) A person has a right of self defence to the extent of causing death to another provided he apprehends death by the act of the letter

Facts Shuva went to a hardware shop owned by Anup. Bargaining on some item led to altercation between the two and Shuva picked up a sharp object and hit at Anup. When Anup started bleeding, his wife Maridula intervened and she was also hit by Shuva and she became unconscious. Finding him self totally cornered, Anup delivered a severe blow to Shuva with a sharp object. Shuva died instantly. Facts Shuva went to a hardware shop owned by Anup. Bargaining on some item led to altercation between the two and Shuva picked up a sharp object and hit at Anup. When Anup started bleeding, his wife Maridula intervened and she was also hit by Shuva and she became unconscious. Finding him self totally cornered, Anup delivered a severe blow to Shuva with a sharp object. Shuva died instantly. Possible decisions (a) Anup murdered Shuva. (b) Anup killed Shuva with the intention of killing to save himself and his wife. (c) Anup killed Shuva without any intention to do so just to save him self and his wife probable reasons for the decision (c) Anup killed Shuva without any intention to do so just to save him self and his wife probable reasons for the decision (i) if a person kills another instantly on the spot, the intention to kill is obvious (ii) Anup used force apprehending death of himself and his wife (iii) Anup used disproportionate force (iv) there was nothing to show that Shuva wanted to kill Anup or his wife