Multiple choice general knowledge math & puzzles A shepherd had 17 sheep. All but nine died. How many was he left with? 0 8 9 17 Reveal answer Fill a bubble to check yourself C Correct answer Explanation This is a classic lateral thinking riddle. 'All but nine died' means that only nine sheep survived. Therefore, the shepherd is left with exactly 9 sheep. The other numbers (0, 8, 17) result from misinterpreting the phrasing.